Either the metaverse is open and people own their stuff, or there is no metaverse — there is just Disneyland: a series of closed simulations operated by a small number of huge corporations. The choice is binary. Open metaverses are built on open protocols, open identity, open data, and ownership that is portable between worlds. NFTs are the technical means by which that ownership is provable; the cultural and political work of insisting on it is what determines whether the metaverse stays open.Punk6529's open-metaverse thread →
NFTs went through the full hype cycle in eighteen months and came out the other side as durable infrastructure. CryptoPunks (Larva Labs, June 2017) were the original — 10,000 24x24 pixel portraits, free to claim, now floor-priced in millions. Yuga Labs' Bored Ape Yacht Club launched April 2021 and became the cultural reference for the 2021-2022 NFT cycle, complete with celebrity holders, the ApeCoin airdrop, and the Otherside metaverse mint that congested Ethereum for hours. Then the floor collapsed and the timeline moved on.
What survived has its own shape. Pudgy Penguins, under Luca Netz's leadership since 2022, became the rare example of an NFT collection that successfully extended into licensed merch (Walmart, Target) and the PENGU token launch in late 2024. Azuki built an anime-style brand and IP universe. Bitcoin Ordinals — Casey Rodarmor's January 2023 inscription protocol — created a parallel NFT ecosystem on Bitcoin that Bitcoiners hated and the fee market loved. Magic Eden, Blur (Pacman's project, the first to airdrop trader-rewards into an NFT marketplace), and Tensor on Solana split the secondary market three ways.
The honest reset is that JPEG-as-status doesn't generalize. NFTs as identity, gaming inventory, ticketing, music ownership, and IP licensing do. Story Protocol is building the IP-licensing-on-chain layer. Sound and Catalog are the music NFT survivors. Tickets via GET Protocol and Tixbase. The Pudgy Penguins playbook — IP first, token second — is the template most surviving collections are running. The 2021 mania priced art. The 2025 reality prices ownership rights, and that is a much larger market.
The founding document.
Six pieces of the NFT stack.
NFTs survived the 2022-23 collapse by becoming infrastructure rather than speculation. ERC-721 is the durable primitive. Royalties became a war about who pays artists. Bitcoin Ordinals proved sat-numbered inscriptions are a real medium. Story Protocol turned IP licensing into a programmable rights layer. Pudgy Penguins shipped the first crypto-native consumer brand into Walmart. Music NFTs reframed who owns a song. Six pieces of the post-bubble NFT thesis.
Dieter Shirley, Jordan Schalm, William Entriken, and Nastassia Sachs's ERC-721 (finalized January 2018, drafted from CryptoKitties' contract) is the standard for unique tokens on Ethereum. Each token has a unique ID, an owner address, and metadata typically pointed at JSON on IPFS. tokenURI returns the metadata location. Approve, transferFrom, ownerOf are the core methods. The standard's durability is the actual story: every NFT marketplace, every L2 NFT collection, every game item that calls itself an NFT speaks ERC-721. The substrate beneath the bubble.
ERC-721 royalties are honored at the marketplace layer, not the protocol layer — the contract emits a creator-fee preference; the marketplace decides whether to enforce it. Blur (2022) launched zero-royalty trading and captured share from OpenSea on speed and efficiency. Creator royalties collapsed across the market within months. Operator filter (Limit Break, 2022) tried to make royalties enforceable by blacklisting non-compliant marketplaces; mostly failed. ERC-2981 standardized the royalty signal but couldn't mandate enforcement. The economic fight reshaped NFT primary-sale economics permanently.
Casey Rodarmor's January 2023 release introduced ordinal theory: each satoshi gets a unique number based on mining order, and arbitrary data inscribed into the witness section of a Taproot transaction is bound to a specific sat. The inscription rides the sat through future transactions. Created an NFT-like primitive entirely on Bitcoin without altering consensus rules — just a new way to interpret existing data. Drove Bitcoin transaction fees to multi-year highs in 2023, sparked the BRC-20 token experiment, and split Bitcoin culture along monetary-purist vs artifact lines.
Story Protocol (S.Y. Lee, 2024) is an EVM-compatible L1 specifically for IP rights. Creators register IP as Programmable IP Assets, attach licensing terms (commercial use, derivative works, royalty splits), and downstream users can license programmatically — the contract enforces the rights. Targets a specific gap: existing IP licensing is bilateral, slow, and gated by lawyers. Story makes it composable. Founded by the team behind Radish Fiction. Backed by a16z's largest round of 2024. The bet: AI-generated content needs a programmable rights layer or it doesn't have rights at all.
Pudgy Penguins launched July 2021 as a 8,888-piece PFP collection, nearly died in 2022, and was acquired by Luca Netz who pivoted it into a consumer IP play — plush toys in Walmart, branded partnerships, the PENGU token launch on Solana in December 2024 with a major airdrop to holders. The thesis: an NFT collection can be the seed for a real consumer brand if the operator treats it like a consumer brand. The penguin plushies move actual retail volume. The reference example for NFT-IP commercialization.
Sound.xyz, Catalog, and Royal launched 2021-2022 with platforms for artists to mint music NFTs — songs as collectibles, sometimes with revenue-share rights attached. Daniel Allan, RAC, 3LAU shipped influential drops. The pitch: streaming pays artists fractions of cents per play; NFTs let one engaged collector pay $50 for a song and own a piece of it. Volume cratered with the NFT market generally. Sound.xyz pivoted, smaller platforms shuttered, the primitive lives on at lower volumes among artists who treat collectors as patrons rather than fans.
Projects we actually watch.
Conviction is stated as conviction; you decide what to do with it. Tiers below — Core, Conviction, Watch, Speculative — reflect how much of FRQNCY's attention each project currently earns, not a recommendation to buy.
Five small things, repeated.
Conviction is theatre without practice. Five steps that turn the thesis above into something the body actually does, not just something the mind agrees with.
Pick by cultural weight. Watch what happens to the floor and to the community. Most lessons take time.
Use Ord wallet or Magic Eden. Pay the sat fee. Feel the philosophical argument with every byte.
Floor-bid liquidity dynamics. The trader airdrop economics rewrote NFT marketplace UX.
Luca Netz's 2022-2024 case study is the canonical post-mania NFT recovery story.
The point of an NFT was always the ledger entry. Move it to a hardware wallet and prove it.
Two doors. Pick one.
The Crypto hub is the index of all sectors and the freedom-technology frame they share. The Fund is what happens when the same conviction gets put to work on behalf of the network.